Feed on
Posts
Comments

(Reposted from True Slant)

In the early years of the anti-abortion movement, supporters argued that eliminating the right to life for the unborn wasn’t just bad for those in the womb (and their mothers). It was also bad for those out of the womb. Once society takes away one class of human being’s right to life, they argued, it will take away another class’ right to life. For decades, it was possible to believe that this line of argument was wrong-headed at best or fear mongering at worst.

But the events of the past two decades have shown that the anti-abortionists’ argument was prophetic, if less dramatic than they predicted. More bad criminals were executed by the state. The frailest of the elderly were euthanized. And in Europe at least, brain-damaged infants were taken off of ventilators.

Now another class of humans is being targeted: infants without a high quality of life. That’s the gist of a story from the Daily Telegraph in Britain. Although I don’t like to post stories in full, I think this story gives you the necessary details:

A British hospital wants to remove a 1-year-old boy born with a rare neuromuscular condition from life support, but the child’s father is fighting to keep him alive.

The baby’s mother agrees with hospital officials, who plan to seek High Court permission Monday to remove the boy from the ventilator that allows him to breathe, British newspapers reported Sunday.

The infant, known only as “Baby RB,” was born with congenital myasthenic syndrome, a muscle weakness that limits the movement of his limbs and his ability to breathe on his own. He has been in the hospital since birth.

Lawyers for the father say the baby’s brain is unaffected by the condition, so that he can see, hear and feel and recognises his parents. He is also able to play with toys and enjoy stories and music, they say.

If the hospital’s application is successful, it would be the first time that a UK court has, against the will of a parent, determined that life support may be withdrawn or discontinued from a child who is not suffering brain damage.

A court order prevents identification of anyone connected to the family or the hospital.

Dependent on a ventilator to breathe, the child has been in hospital since birth.

His father, in his twenties and who is amicably separated from the mother, believes a simple tracheostomy procedure, which creates an opening in the neck to deliver oxygen to the lungs, would allow Baby RB to be discharged from hospital to be cared for at home.

But the hospital, backed by the child’s mother, says the baby’s quality of life is so low that it would not be in his best interests to save him.

In an attempt to persuade the court that Baby RB’s quality of life is such that the hospital trust’s application should be refused, the father will submit video footage showing his son playing with his toys and interacting with his parents, who have both been at their son’s side since his birth, living at dedicated family accommodation near the hospital.

Christopher Cuddihee, a solicitor who is acting for the father, said: “This is a tragic case. The father feels very strongly that Baby RB has a quality of life that demands the trust should continue to provide life-sustaining treatment. The father clearly adores his son and hopes to demonstrate to the court that the trust’s application should be rejected.”

Congenital myasthenic syndrome is the result of a gene abnormality affecting the junction between the nerve and the muscle, disrupting the ’signal’ between the two when the nerve wants the muscle to contract – resulting in muscle weakness and ‘floppy’ limbs.

Degrees of severity vary tremendously among the 300 people in the UK with the condition. The most commonly affected – and obvious – muscles are those in the face, resulting in a telltale inability to smile. Those around the eyes are particularly affected, leading to leading to double vision and droopy eyelids.

The premise of the wife’s and hospital’s argument, and the husband’s too to an extent, is that quality of life should determine whether a person lives or dies. The boy can’t breathe on his own, so he should die, one side argues; the boy can play with toys, so he should live, another side argues. What should be obvious to everyone, I think, is that quality of life is an inherently subjective criteria.

It’s also a bad criteria. Quality of life is what some philosophers call a secondary characteristic of humanity, just as race and gender are. It’s not a primary one. All humans are whole, separate, and unique. When society turns its back on this standard, I’m afraid to say, it seems to be only a matter of time before your group will be targeted. Think of it as like the final scene in Peckinpah’s Bring Me the Head of Alfredo Garcia: Sooner or later, the gun will be pointed at you.

Before the month runs out, I need to post this hymn.

Readers of this blog will likely guess the answer to this question. But you might find my reasoning interesting. Click here to read my post at TrueSlant.

Tom Monaghan hasn’t gotten much love in the press lately, even from those who should be in his corner — Christian traditionalists. Rod Dreher criticized the pizza mogul as little more than an incompetent bully, while Mark Shea gave him the back of his hand. But over at True Slant, I make the case that Monaghan’s legacy is more complicated. Here is an excerpt:

For one thing, Monaghan has been an active Catholic benefactor. His money helped build a new cathedral in Nicaragua, which had been ruined by an earthquake in 1972, and it helped defeat an abortion-rights referendum in Michigan. For another thing, Monaghan seeks to do more than create a good Catholic university; he wants to build a great one that will influence the culture. As [Peter] Boyer writes of Monaghan’s goals,

A university could train young people who would, in turn, train the next generation of priests, teachers, nuns, and school principals. “You’ve got to create a sort of critical mass,” he said. “If we can get priests who are turned on to the faith, then you have a good congregation. It’s a multiplication. If you have a good principal, you have a good school. If you have a good catechism teacher, you have a good child. So you’re not catechizing one person, you’re catechizing thousands and thousands. And not just in one locality but all over the world. That’s why the university is such an efficient thing–a tool to change the world.”

There are already more than two hundred Catholic colleges and universities in the United States, but, in Monaghan’s view, though some are great universities, none are great Catholic universities. Notre Dame has become the sort of institution that stages “The Vagina Monologues.” The Jesuit-run University of San Francisco offers students a minor in gender and sexuality studies. Some schools, like Manhattanville College and Marist College, have surrendered their Catholic identity. Other Catholic schools, such as Franciscan University, in Steubenville, Ohio (of which Monaghan was the principal benefactor), and Thomas Aquinas College, in Santa Paula, California, were resolutely orthodox but had no ambitions to become first-tier research institutions. Monaghan was looking for a high-level academic institution that was also, as he puts it, “seriously Catholic.”

If you’re a traditional or orthodox Catholic like me, you’ll be impressed by Monaghan’s accomplishments and ambitions for his faith. But there’s a problem. How should we square his successes and goals with his heavy-handed and bullying tactics? The jury, I think, is still out on this question. On the one hand, Monaghan treated those below him – administrators, faculty, alumni, students – more like Larry Ellison or George Steinbrenner than popes John Paul II or Benedict XVI. On the other hand, Monaghan created and built the first Catholic university and law school in America in 50 years.

I thought of this question a lot over the past year. Now Catholic prelates will need to turn it over in their minds: What to do about burying Ted Kennedy? Should he receive a funeral befitting a flawed but virtuous man or a great sinner with some notable qualities?

Over at True Slant, I attempted to make sense of Kennedy’s passing. Here is an excerpt:

The good Ted Kennedy did more perhaps to help the poor, disabled, and marginalized than any American politician in the last two generations. A partial list of the bills he sponsored or shepherded to passage reveals a breadth of support for groups that only Lyndon Johnson or Franklin Roosevelt could match: The bilingual Education Act; the Fair Housing Acts; the Age Discrimination Act; the South African sanctions; the Federal Disabilities Act, and the Children’s Health-Insurance Program.

The bad Ted Kennedy honored politicians who threatened the poor, disabled, and marginalized. When George C. Wallace in February 1974 announced his candidacy for a third term as governor of Alabama, he noted that several prominent Northern politicians had flown to the state capitol of Birmingham to kiss his ring. One of those was Kennedy, who contemplated running for president in 1976, a time when the South was still up for grabs. All of those Northerners, Wallace told his followers at a morning press conference, had but one message: “How great thou art in Alabama!”

In case you’re asking yourself the same question, and you know you are as a viewer of the town hall meetings about health care, check out my answers over at True Slant. Here is an excerpt from today’s post:

Klein’s argument strikes me as partly correct: During the second Bush administration, Democratic leaders did not retail the false statements, lies, and rumors of progressive activists, though John Kerry’s contention in the 2004 campaign that Bush would likely reinstate the draft is surely an exception to the rule. But his argument is also partly false. Has he forgotten Ted Kennedy’s famous harangue on the Senate floor of Supreme Court nominee Robert Bork in 1987. Or how about Andrew Sullivan’s contention, one that he continues to hold, that Sarah Palin faked her last pregnancy or Gloria Steinem’s statement that Palin “shares only a chromosone” with Hillary Clinton. That’s not asymmetric extremism; that symmetric extremism.

Gone Fishin’

Posting will be light this weekend and next week. I will be visiting my family and friends out West. I’d like to post a few times, but anything more than that would be realistic. Hey, I got my 20th high school reunion, two Giants games, golf, and the racetrack to go to.

Conservatives are making a lot of claims about a provision in a House version of the legislation that would pay doctors to consult with seniors every five years about their end-of-life care. Some are bogus. Others are not. Over at True Slant, I argue that the provision does open the door to euthanasia:

As Wesley J. Smith notes, if Blumenauer’s provision becomes law, more than a few doctors would be influenced by publications such as the “Caring Conversations” workbook of the Center for Practical Bioethics. It assumes that unless patients can achieve “quality of life” they should not receive care.

In addition to “quality of life” considerations, other doctors will add one more consideration: cost containment. Many progressives deny or reject this claim, but some liberal ethicists admit that it’s true, though they don’t say so explicitly. In The Washington Post last week, a bioethicist had this to say about end-of-life care:

“I don’t think it’s about cutting costs; it’s about quality,” said Tia Powell, director of the Montefiore-Einstein Center for Bioethics. Pointing to extensive research, she said: “The good news is if you get people in an environment that is of their choosing, where there is support and they have good pain control, it is very likely to extend their life.”

It goes without saying that Mollie Hemingway and Douglas LeBlanc at my old employer tell pretty much all you need to know about the press’ mostly inadequate treatment of the fight over abortion coverage in health insurance legislation and the New York Times‘ profile of the late Dr. George Tiller and his opponents.

It’s one thing to support the legalization of artificial contraception, which strikes me as bad for the republic but impossible to reverse. But it’s another to support federal funding of Planned Parenthood. Why should tax dollars go to an organization that performs abortions? If this were the mid-19th century, no opponent of slavery, not even Lincoln, would support federal funding for slaveowners in hopes of reducing the number of slaves.

Which is why I think that contra William Saletan, conservative pro-lifers’ opposition to the so-called abortion reduction bill is not “militant.” And which is why the votes of pro-life Democrats against the amendment to defund the organization is worthy of condemnation. (Tip o’ the hat to Deal Hudson)

(Image used under a Creative Commons license courtesy of seamusiv.com)

Update: Via Mark Shea, a Harvard senior research scientist concludes that in Africa at least, condoms are no solution to the AIDS epidemic:

Condoms fail because people do not use them consistently, because they are not used once people get to know someone, and because they provide a false sense of security, allowing people to take greater risks then they would take if condoms were not used at all.

Older Posts »

zetia buying online tramadol drugs that relieve pain cialis comparison help for arthritis acne prescription treatments ramipril capsule flu vaccine body building products osteoporosis and exercise phentermine with no prescription what is high blood pressure buy imipramine online where can i buy phentermine online osteoporosis medication side effects no prescription klonopin herbal breast enhancers professional viagra diuretic medicines ativan pills health med online problem skin bone loss zolpidem dosage clomipramine asthma attack treatment cheap order buy teeth whitening wellbutrin 150 xl sleeping disorder information information on ambien buy pain medacine online nausea medication dog health care pain behind knee nolvadex generic anti anxiety medications teeth whitening california viagra cheap buy online generic abilify alternate herbal viagra breast enhancing drug cialis 20 mg hypnotherapy course treatment for hepatitis b acyclovir hair loss treatment prices back pain medications obesity care relief from back pain free phentermine overactive bladder medications bladder control women urinary tract infection treatment how to use clomid meloxicam tablets pain meds without prescriptions what valium does onset of action in valium buy clotrimazole care for a cat hoodia gordonni buy imipramine online bone health problems stop pain how to buy pain meds online tooth whitening procedures levitra cheap online valium with no prescription attention deficit blood pressure meds avodart prescription allergy asthma child health med clean dogs ears phentermine online prilosec 20 fluconazole interaction smoking treatment control pain cialis soft tabs online drugs without prescription robaxin dosage online purchase viagra healthy weight loss program valtrex new stop smoking medication naturally lower cholesterol blood pressure shoulder pain pain meds without prescriptions allergy prevention atenolol 25mg ramipril generic online paxil buy vardenafil online cheap pain meds viagra online purchase treatment for hypertension itching ointment cheep daily cialis kamagra generic diet weight loss back pain relief products cialis softgel klonopin mg dose phentermine 37.5 mg cold sores help body building sites increase women intimacy prescription for acne viagra and sports valium sold in usa phentermine 30mg no prescription condoms buy pain relief product back muscle pain dog seperation anxiety different treatments of alcoholism how to control pain treatment for dry skin zestril medication teeth whitening methods metformin attention deficit disorder help generic cheap viagra ativan prescription effects of folic acid excessive body odo breast growth drug help for adhd irritable bowel syndrome bronchitis medications anti wrinkles norvasc dose breast enhancement product side effects of ativan post pregnancy weight loss elevated blood pressure crestor dosage phentermine without perscription cialis softgel weight loss products order antibiotic cheap sublingual viagra ambien and side effects levitra viagra cialis low price benefits hyaluronic acid buy avandia medicine for vomiting information on cholesterol order metformin online buy prescription drugs on line bactrim online best price for cialis pregnancy and weight loss Cialis And Purchase prices soft tab cialis erythromycin pregnancy new blood pressure treatment new cancer treatments build muscle mexican tramadol baclofen prilosec 20 immune stimulants new products for hair loss buy cialis online now ultram information treatment of human parasites bust enhance tramadol 100 mg buy viagra eye pain beta blocker uses bronchitis pregnancy online prilosec alprazolam no perscription medication for anxiety phentermine with no perscription no prescription needed phentermine home scabies treatment cure blood clot allopurinol drug buy pain medications tadalafil jelly xenical mexico prescriptions total health shop breast enhancement natural easy weight loss treatment dementia ramipril generic latest diet pill buying viagra online on-line pharmacy clonazepam .5mg vs valium hair loss disease cialis herbal herbs for impotence antibiotic natural body building training bladder control women help for heart failure how do i order viagra online buy periactin new treatment for allergies help for depression weight loss food back pain online sildenafil pharmacy online geodon drugs depression phenytoin sleep disorders treatment ativan order generic imitrex post pregnancy weight loss alprazolam meds for high blood pressure breast enlargement info menopause cures antibiotics for cat side effects zoloft products for back pain super viagra skin infections urinary tract health tooth whitening dentistry motilium medications for depression and anxiety viagra cialis levitra celebrex celebrex lowest price on plan b cures for erectile dysfunction cialis 50mg buy cialis online in usa ranitidine medication total health discount skin cancer treatments chronic snoring cheapest generic cialis weight loss after birth acne prescription general health tips plan b safe care health pet jelly viagras weight loss information muscle strength lowest price generic viagra natural breast enhancer hair loss treatment uk what is clomid dog medications cephalexin tricor tablets risperdal anxiety viagra china antibiotics and dogs acne medication online mass muscle lexapro 10 mg how to buy viagra online stress drug health remedies for dogs shingles treatments body fat lose cat's eye health alzheimer drugs allergy medicine viagra on line uk pharmacy drug prices pain products prevention of heart attack buy sumycin skin fungal infection price of drugs how to treat flu dog skin disorder xanax buy on line online weight loss us levitra professional cialis osteoporosis exercise online drug stores how to enlarge the breast nausea vomiting levitra online pharmacy control of pain alternative hair loss cures erythromycin penicillin about zocor propecia without prescription generic abilify does alli work hair loss products medications for diabetes buy abana purchase cialis online without prescription drug given for malaria naturally increase breast size weight loss medicine buy online breast enhancing drug buy imipramine online stress pills stomach pain relief reducing blood pressure accutane buy natural remedies for constipation menopause gum allergy asthma child order viagra plus clomid prescription ativan medication no prescription cialis online cialis prescription online professional tooth whitening high blood calcium level luvox cr us levitra order vermox tablets hiv drugs suffering produces endurance prices of drugs dental whitening products natural hair loss treatment hydroxyzine dose cialis versus viagra hair loss remedy teeth whitening products antibiotic medicine cialis viagra vs kamagra asthma cures woman and viagra antifungal scalp vitamin teeth whitening prices face wrinkles buy mojo maxx back pain medicine paxil purchase viagra online without prescription bone loss generic price viagra phentermine without prescription diarrhea women reducing blood pressure ultram online cheap levitra prescription lopid blood clot treatments prevention of heart attack strattera generic abilify 10mg new blood pressure treatment crestor dosage prescription drugs the cialis anxiety symptoms treatments zyprexa buy griseofulvin without prescription heart rate treatments total health vitamins colostrum acne cure pills ivermectin tramadol high control bleeding medical treatment for diabetes arthritis therapy cialis purchase online really large breast enhancement cialis contraindications bronchitis vs pneumonia where to buy viagra on line natural cholesterol control xanax online without a prescrption high blood pressure in elderly buy cheap cialis mass muscle online pain doctors phentermine buy hair loss hair care information cetirizine effects relief foot pain body building tips muscle pain help for constipation left heart failure generika levitra vitamin a drugs depression losartan viagra best buy pharmacy alprazolam ways to enhance breast dog teeth problems cialis 20 depression therapy drugs lower blood pressure skin spots new osteoporosis treatments general health mysoline anti depression treating fungal infection weight loss help cialis soft erythromycin pregnancy increase erection cheap celadrin prices levitra buy cialis without a perscription zyvox buy nimotop jellys sildenafil dog digestive system parasite cleanser generika levitra treating hair loss zyrtec online cheap buy viagra nutritional diet for osteoporosis viagra prescription breast cancer support atlas rx viagra family pharmacy skin spots allergy asthma child antifungal treatment cure for gout phentermine to buy can i get a viagra today fluconazole capsule wrinkle face teeth whitening products pyridium asthma medications pharmacy software rocaltrol drugs for alzheimer's neurontin medication best fat blockers how to enlarge breast viagra online buy viagra on line quit smoking programs really large breast enhancement online prilosec gout medicines dog products uk
temperture
knows
microprocessor
womens
flooding
vinny
warren
mechanicsville
thornhill
prayers
beak
automatically
reservoir
enemies
sellers
kawasaki
browns
pleasanton
gaston
tyre
ionizer
fryer
filled
orthopedics
vessels
brazil
merlin
qt
niles
solicitors
blink
stores
pcl
choice
waterproofing
diagnostics
jenifer
jab
histology
literacy
wrath
schooner
wma
aboard
inter
indulgence
staind
soak
investments
juli
steady
terence
crest
survive
paraguay
kayaks
viewsonic
shitting
periodicals
shoppers
contribution
pontiac
gilles
enfant
explicit
trois
skiing
sandler
slug
cupcake
commercial
firestone
til
counts
robot
reclining
luxe
killswitch
spouse
sandpoint
attraction
checklist
jerky
soul
ultima
clare
reebok
abrasive
witness
imperial
pennington
titanic
caterpillar
braces
expedia
insane
confederate
alex
custom
wording
launch
switched
hyatt
jeremy
shy
hiring
jab
salomon
adirondack
shultz
u2
dooley
ter
tracer
kyoto
quit
guaranty
autoclave
bjork
youngstown
sunfire
miners
falcons
vertical
nih
dominique
kenosha
loren
landers
martini
microwaves
bunny
alloy
classic
heated
attendant
suunto
shultz
partnership
dementia
rosenthal
release
gregory
maxim
powerbook
electrode
hotel
lexmark
geral
india
rhinestones
park
mansion
bandage
forestry
bowser
av
pairing
deptford
kruger
greens
hdpe
uxbridge
isdn
exposure
sicilian
waddell
burmese
sheena
jcpenney
valid
linux
caesars
enviro
ringo
critic
fake
yearbook
decrypt
holding
dig
montecito
canyon
aggie
earnest
regions
adhd
needed
gastro
ebay
increases
cries
wav
suit
quebec
craiglist
fundraisers
attractive
trimming
conneticut
tester
ronald
mutant
digging
clovis
designing
logical
sharma
propulsion
saints
christiana
psychiatric
hin
pentax
bowes
pomeroy
collie
retarded
tappan
engraving
guages
woodwork
plano
elemental
starts
pcb
raised
yiff
wrapped
microsystems
dm
camoflage
menu
sounds
alpha
potatoe
animals
brokerage
savvy
owa
infringement
amortization
turning
seekers
mce
plows
frames
ninja
birthstone
vita
crop
tonight
swings
executives
stylish
jbl
chime
earring
funniest
camoflauge
carvings
hilfiger
millionaire
workflow
gatwick
intersection
purdue
travis
chicagoland
walkthru
lockdown
traders
southampton
lotto
railing
svc
hiroshima
parabolic
yankovic
coolant
centerville
brantford
compaq
batavia
captial
doomsday
replaced
keyboarding
manifest
southington
spill
blvd
sprout
hawker
written
sunscreen
wreath
galaxies
significance
path
imdb
nina